Essie Fall 2011 Brand New Bag Collection – Case Study, Power Clutch and Carry On, Swatches and Comparisons

by Laura on July 30, 2011

Essie Power Clutch

Essie Power Clutch

I’ve been stalking WalGreen’s for weeks, hoping to come upon Essie’s Fall 2011 collection, Brand New Bag.  There’s several empty shelves right at the front of my store, so I can tell there’s new fall products en route, but nothing has been forthcoming.  I finally drove to an out-of-the-way store I never visit, and there it was, tucked right into the normal Essie display.  Swatches coming up!

I picked up the four Brand New Bag polishes that were available at the store for now, but I left Lady Like for another post (click here to read my Lady Like review), and I’ll save my further musings on distribution of the collection for the end of this post.  The Essie brush is skinny and a nice texture so it’s easy to work with, and all four of the colors from this collection have really nice creme formulas, and took only two coats.  I decided to start with Case Study, a dark khaki color with strong greenish undertones.  This one reminded me of the murky greens that have been kicking around this summer, like Essie’s Da Bush.  It’s much more brown, though.  I liked it, but it was almost too much-the darker brown plus the slightly sicky green tone were just a little meh on my skin.  But I do like that it’s more subtle than the greener colors from the summer.  It’s totally work appropriate, with just a little bit of shiver underneath.

Essie Case Study

Essie Case Study

The shade picture shows the green tone more strongly.

Essie Case Study

Essie Case Study

kittytokaren at PolishorPerish speculated that Case Study might be just a re-promote of Milky Way, but when I saw the bottle I could tell that Case Study was more green.  Milky Way is the J.Crew exclusive camel color from this spring.  I’m a Milky Way fan; I love its delicate warmth and slight pink tone.  In the picture below, Case Study is on my index and middle finger and Milky Way is on my ring and pinky.  You can see when they’re side by side that they’re really different (and that Milky Way is a lot more flattering, on me anyway).  Milky Way sadly was only sold through J. Crew and is not available anymore, but we’ll have to keep hoping for a re-release (you can read my original Milky Way review here.  Judging from pictures, one of the non-retail polishes from the Brand New Bag Collection (Glamour Purse) is a warmer taupe that might be closer to Milky Way.

Essie Case Study, Milky Way

Essie Case Study, Milky Way

 

Essie Case Study, Milky Way

Essie Case Study, Milky Way

Next is Power Clutch.  The formula on this one was also really nice and only took two coats.  It’s a dark grey that also has a hint of green in it, which makes it more interesting.  I really liked this one, more than I was expecting.  It’s somehow richer and more complex than most greys, I think because it doesn’t lean blue like so many can.  It’s not so dark that it looks black, and just seems very sophisticated, perfect for wearing to work or with a weekend outfit.  This one is definitely my favorite of the collection so far.

Essie Power Clutch

Essie Power Clutch

The green tone was noticeable while I was wearing it but difficult to photograph.  This picture shows it a bit; in dim lighting it peeks out a bit more.  It’s almost the kind of thing you see more out of the corner of your eye than when you’re looking straight at it.  Sort of like the Pleiades.

Essie Power Clutch

Essie Power Clutch

I compared it to Deborah Lippmann’s Billionaire, a new dark green from her fall collection.  Power Clutch is on my index and middle fingers and Billionaire is on my ring and pinky below.  It’s funny how much lighter and more blue-grey Power Clutch suddenly appears when it’s next to Billionaire.  The dark, smoky green in Billionaire just crushes the subtle tones in Power Clutch.

Essie Power Clutch, Billionaire

Essie Power Clutch, Billionaire

Next is Carry On.  This color is a dark purple that has red undertones.  It also took only two easy coats for opacity and applied well.  I like this take on a dark purple-it’s dramatic, but not blackish.  It has more of a dark brown feel, and seems warmer than a lot of other colors like this that are dark and purplish.  It reminded me of raisins.  Carry On is a nice color for autumn, and I might even work up the nerve to wear it at work–in indoor lighting it’s borderline too dark, but it’s clearly not black so it might be okay…

Essie Carry On

Essie Carry On

 

Essie Carry On

Essie Carry On

In the bottle I thought it would be easy to find lots of similar colors, but Carry On is darker and more purple than the other similar colors I have.  The only color I have that was close is Rescue Beauty’s Recherche.  Carry On is on my index and middle fingers, and Recherche is on my ring and pinky below.  Carry On has a stronger red tone than Recherche, which is more smoky and a darker purple.  They’re not the same color, but they are pretty close, especially in dim lighting when the red in Carry On fades out a bit and it seems darker.

Essie Carry On, Recherche

Essie Carry On, Recherche

 

A word about the distribution of Fall 2011 – it seems to be following the French Affair pattern (only 4 of the 6 polishes stuck into the top section of the normal Essie display) rather than the Brazilliant pattern (all 6 polishes, displayed in their own little seasonal plastic-y thing on the shelves near the front of the store).  I’m disappointed that all 6 of the Brand New Bag colors aren’t available on the retail side (yet), but I’m going to try to hold off on buying the other two, Very Structured and Glamour Purse.  With French Affair, I found that a few drugstores eventually ended up with all six polishes displayed on a little seasonal thing–the other two polishes did exist in their retail form, just not as widely distributed.  Interestingly, the stores that eventually had the rarer two colors in retail packaging were the ones with smaller or really tiny normal Essie displays.  They seem like the stores that wouldn’t move as much Essie in the first place–why they would get to be the ones to get the full collection, I don’t know.  So anyway, I’m still hoping that the other two polishes from Brand New Bag will eventually show up in at least a few random drugstores and I’ll be able to get the retail versions that way.  I’m really eyeing the burnt orange color, Very Structured.

Update:

I have managed to track down and swatch all of the polishes from the Brand New Bag Collection.  Check out the previously mentioned review of Lady Like and my review of the final two colors, Glamour Purse and Very Structured, to see the whole collection.  Let me know your thoughts on them below.  Thanks for reading!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

Kathleen August 6, 2011 at 5:42 pm

LOVE this review on Essie’s nail polishes! i have yet to buy my own, but i definitely love how you showed us comparisons between each kind. gotta go make a trip now to buy some! :)
p.s. now following your blog lovely!

<3, Kathleen.

Reply

Laura August 8, 2011 at 9:36 pm

Thanks for your comment! It’s so nice to hear.

Reply

Fabuless Beauty August 8, 2011 at 12:22 pm

Thanks for sharing! I love Carry On!

Reply

Laura August 8, 2011 at 9:37 pm

I agree Carry On is really pretty! I can see wearing it a lot this fall.

Reply

Rach August 8, 2011 at 11:30 pm

Wow, thank you for sharing these comparison pictures! This is extremely helpful, as I was wondering how close Power Clutch and Billionaire would be. I’ve seen both polishes in the wild, but I didn’t expect Power Clutch to look quite so dusty next to Billionaire! Keep up the great work. :)

Reply

Laura August 9, 2011 at 6:53 am

Thanks! I didn’t expect that either – Power Clutch and Billionaire look much less similar when they’re side by side than I thought they would be.

Reply

Emily August 18, 2011 at 12:31 pm

Love your swatches! Now I have new polishes on my wish list :) Do you happen to know if Carry On might be a dupe to OPI We’ll Always have Paris? The Essie Fall 2011 collection is not in my area yet :( for me to compare.

Reply

Laura August 19, 2011 at 7:36 am

Thanks for your comment! Unfortunately I don’t have OPI’s We’ll Always Have Paris to compare to Carry On. I checked pictures online, and just from pictures it looks to me like We’ll Always Have Paris might be redder and browner than Carry On-on the nail Carry On is very much a muted purple color.

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 4 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: